We have compiled a list of the very best Josh Allen rookie cards that show this highly rated quarterback in all his glory.
If you haven’t yet taken notice of quarter-back Josh Allens sports cards, you really should. This centerpiece of the Buffalo Bills offense has some tremendous collectables that have only grown in rarity and demand over the past few years.
As the seventh pick in the 2018 NFL Draft taken after Baker Mayfield and Sam Darnold. Josh Allen rookie cards have been seeing strong demand as the young quarterback consistently puts in big performances to the point where many would now consider him top tier.
It is therefore no wonder his cards are so valued. However some are worth a lot more than others due to their rarity, design and when they were issued.
1. 2018 Panini Prestige NFL Josh Allen #234
- Approximate PSA 10 value – $120
- Approximate PSA 9 value – $65
This retail exclusive card was popular when it was first released in 2018.
Compared to many other Allen cards which have risen tremendously in price since then this Prestige edition offers a far more generous price point. Making it a good option for new collectors just getting into the hobby of card collecting.
With the Buffalo Bills logo in the bottom right and the RC logo shining brightly in the left. This card is not expected to rise hugely in value.
2. Josh Allen 2018 Score Rookie RC #350
- Approximate PSA 10 value – $150
- Approximate PSA 9 value – $44
Score cards have been around since the 1980’s and are therefore considered by many collectors to be more of a vintage line.
In fact, out of the 2018 set Allen’s card is by far the most valuable with Lamar Jackson being just behind him but selling for a fraction of what this Allen card goes for on the market.
The card itself features the classic Score border and shows Allen in his white Wyoming kit with ball in hand.
The back gives a detailed description of Allen’s stats during his Wyoming 2017 season and a brief description on his victory over Central Michigan during the Idaho Potato Bowl.
One of his best performances to date where he managed to make a pass that resulted in a 23-yard score.
3. Panini Illusions Josh Allen, Jim Kelly #19
- Approximate PSA 10 value – $450
- Approximate PSA 9 value – $200
While the Panini Illusions are often advertised and sold as one of the cheaper and more affordable sets for collectors on a smaller budget. Their prices can rise considerably especially in excellent condition.
This Josh Allen Illusions edition from 2018 has already begun increasing in price.
4. 2018 Donruss Rated Rookie Football Josh Allen #304
- Approximate PSA 10 value – $325
- Approximate PSA 9 value – $75
If you’ve ever seen a Josh Allen card before you started collecting or while searching for other editions, chances are it was probably what many people consider Allen’s signature, the Donruss Rookie card.
This card which features Allen proudly handling the ball with a clear blue sky behind him is a must buy for any sports card fans looking to fill up their Bills collection.
Additionally, if you take a look at the price ranges for the 2018 Donruss football cards, Allen is by far the highest even when ungraded but if the card is graded at PSA 10
5. 2018 Panini Playoff #205 Josh Allen
- Approximate PSA 10 value – $330
- Approximate PSA 9 value – $90
While the Panini Playoff sets are known to start quite cheap, the rise in value is pretty impressive. With this Allen card now being heavily sought after since its release.
In terms of value the 2018 Prizm auto version is nothing to slouch at.
An extremely sought after card by many fans looking to finish off their collection.
6. Josh Allen 2018 Classic Base RC #207
- Approximate PSA 10 value – $200
- Approximate PSA 9 value – $40
There was a point around a year ago where the value of this card had dropped by a chunk. However it has since risen higher in top grades.
The card features a determined looking Allen making a long pass as he is known to do. In his familiar brown and gold Wyoming kit that pays homage to his earlier playing career.
On the back there is a detailed table focusing on his 2017 career. Which stood out as one of his best in terms of performance. Along with a general description about his upbringing cleaning at his mothers work.
What really makes it stand out is the stunning appearance. With a sharp border that fades from yellow to black and a blurred background.
7. 2018 Panini National Treasures Josh Allen RPA #163
- Approximate PSA 10 value – $100,000
- Approximate PSA 9 value – $65,000
It’s hard to talk about a player’s very best cards and and not mention National Treasures. This card has a population of just 2 in PSA 10 condition.
A recent Goldin auction saw National Treasures Josh Allen Rookie Patch Auto #163 card achieve a whopping $109,200.00. It was in PSA 10 condition.
With a massive patch and on-card signature and a print run of just 99 copies. You can be sure that this is an incredibly rare and exclusive card. Only the biggest of Allen fans will have it in their possession due to its massive price point.
8. 2018 Panini National Treasures Collegiate Josh Allen RC Auto Patch #103
- Approximate PSA 10 value – $2,000
- Approximate PSA 9 value – $800
Many collectors would consider the National Treasures Collegiate as the little brothers to the National Treasures.
They’re definitely not as flashy and won’t fetch as high of a price. There are lots of variations of this card available with a mix of populations and prices.
An homage to his early career. This Allen Treasures Collegiate card features the quarterback in his Wyoming Cowboys kit. With the University of Wyoming plastered just above the patch and autograph.
9. 2018 Panini Contenders Josh Allen RC Ticket Autograph #105
- Approximate PSA 10 value – $2,200
- Approximate PSA 9 value – $1,500
Many collectors and investors are all about the autographs. After all this adds a tremendous amount of rarity to a card and makes it feel that much more authentic.
The Panini Contenders are the kings when it comes strictly to autographs. The major reasoning for this is due to some of the earliest sets featuring autographs from the likes of Peyton Manning and Tom Brady.
Followers of these sets have been clamoring for more of their favorite players to get their time to shine. They didn’t have to wait long for Josh Allen to get his turn in 2018 with the card featuring a Rookie Ticket to the right.
An image of Allen stanced and ready for a pass to the left and his autograph right below. If you’re all about the autographs, this is a premium Josh Allen card that is one of the hottest out there right now.
10. 2018 Panini Encased Josh Allen RC Auto Hat #105
- Approximate PSA 10 value – $3,500
- Approximate PSA 9 value – $825
At first, this card fitted with an autograph and stylised patch may not seem too out of the ordinary to most other cards.
However when you take into account that only 25 copies exist, it makes sense why the prices for this card so tremendously high and why consider it to be one of the quarterbacks rarest cards.
It’s incredible how much is packed in such a small card. With a hard signature included and even a swatch which comes from a cap actually worn by Allen himself.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Josh Allen Cards Projected To Rise In Value?
A question that every card collector must ask themselves when looking into buying the cards of a specific player is how their value is going to fare in the long time.
After all there have been so many cases where young prospects have caught the attention of collectors. Only for them to fall of tremendously which in turn diminished a lot of the quality.
Luckily, this is almost guaranteed not to be the case with Josh Allen. Just recently in 2022 Goldin Auctions sold a 2018 Panini National Treasures Card of Allen for a staggering $312 thousan. Which is the most one of his cards have ever sold for at auction.
This purchase not only made headlines for how much sports cards are actually worth these days. It made clear that Allen’s cards were here to stay and only likely to increase in value.
Allen has signed an extension with the Bills through to the 2028 season. Considering how much of a great start he has already had with them. There’s no doubt he’s only going to improve and so will the value of his cards.
There’s never been a better time for sports card enthusiasts to take notice of Josh Allen’s rookie cards. Especially now that his rise to stardom in the NFL has been realized.
These are definitely a few rookie cards you will want to keep an eye on.